Choosing a family lawyer? Here’s how to choose well, whoever you hire.

You’re about to hand one person the most private parts of your life: your marriage, your money, your children. And you’re doing it at one of the worst moments you’ll ever have. It’s hard to know what to ask, and it’s easy to worry about picking someone who disappears after you’ve paid.

This page is meant to help you choose well, even if the lawyer you choose isn’t me. Talk to more than one if you can. Ask the hard questions. Then pick the person you trust.

The short answer. Look for three things: a lawyer you can talk to, who will keep you informed; real experience settling cases, preparing them for trial and trying them; and a clean licence, which you can check yourself in two minutes. Every Tennessee lawyer must keep you reasonably informed and explain the basis of their fee. A lawyer can’t charge a family-law fee that depends on getting you the divorce or a certain amount of support or property. And what you tell a lawyer at a consultation stays private, even if you don’t hire them.

Prefer to talk? Book a free consultation or call (615) 649-6841

4.8 on Google · 23 reviews
Free printable checklist

Meeting lawyers this week? Get the full Questions to ask any family lawyer checklist.

Take it to every consultation, by phone, video or in person, and you’ll leave each one knowing exactly how that lawyer would handle your case.

  • About thirty questions, grouped: experience, how they’ll keep you informed, cost, and your case
  • Red flags to tick off as you listen
  • What to bring, so you don’t waste your free consultation
  • A side-by-side grid to compare up to three lawyers when you’re home
Thank you. Your checklist is below.

No waiting for an email: your checklist opens right here on this page. I may send an occasional note from my office; unsubscribe any time.

If you can’t receive or download this guide safely, or are concerned about your spouse seeing it, please call me directly at 615-649-6841.

What should I look for in a family lawyer?

Someone you can work with. It’s real important that the attorney and the client work well together and that the relationship is one that meets the client’s needs and personality, because it’s already a stressful situation. You don’t need your attorney to add more stress to it.

So sit down with the lawyer and decide first whether or not you like them. Not everybody likes the same kind of personality. If you need encouragement and you want somebody to talk to you and listen to you, you want a lawyer who’s willing to do that.

Experience at every stage. It’s important for the lawyer to be experienced in settling cases, in preparing cases for trial, and in being a strong advocate at trial. It doesn’t matter how good a lawyer is in the courtroom if they don’t properly prepare for the trial.

Someone who starts with your goals. The most important thing is to find someone who has the experience, knowledge, and ability to help you meet your goals. A good first meeting should leave you clearer about what you want your life to look like when this is over.

My answer, for comparison: I’ve been licensed in Tennessee since 1983. I settle many cases, and I’ve tried divorces that lasted half a day and nine days. Early on, I sit down with you and help you determine what your end goal is.

How can I check a lawyer’s licence and record?

The Board of Professional Responsibility, set up by the Tennessee Supreme Court, handles lawyer discipline in Tennessee (Tenn. Sup. Ct. R. 9), and its lawyer records are public.

Check any lawyer in three steps

  1. Go to the Board of Professional Responsibility’s site, tbpr.org, and use its Attorney Search to look the lawyer up by name.
  2. Open their record. It shows whether the licence is active, the year they were licensed, and their law school.
  3. Look for public discipline. A clean record says “No Public Discipline.”

Here is mine, so you can see what one looks like: Brenda Clark, BPR no. 010588. Licensed in Tennessee since 1983, active, no public discipline.

How do I avoid a lawyer who won’t call me back?

Start with what the rules already require. Every Tennessee lawyer must keep a client reasonably informed about their case and promptly answer reasonable requests for information (Tenn. Sup. Ct. R. 8, RPC 1.4).

But a rule doesn’t tell you how a particular lawyer works day to day, so ask. How will you update me, and how often? Will I get copies of what’s filed and the letters you send? Who answers when you’re in court? How quickly do you usually call back? Listen for specific answers, not “don’t worry about it.”

How I work: I send you a copy of everything filed or sent in your case, so you know what’s going on every step of the way. If I talk to the lawyer on the other side, you’ll know. I always take your phone call or return your phone call. If someone hires me, I’m going to talk to them.

How I work with clients, from the first call to after the case

“I decided a long time ago if I needed an attorney, I would want someone who is knowle[d]geable, passionate, and possesses integrity. Thanks to a very dear friend, I found that in Brenda Clark. She is supportive and available! Ms. Clark will guide and direct you through your situation based on her thorough understanding of the law. She is always my recommendation when anyone that I know is in need of legal advice and help! She’s superb!”
DD D., Google review

What should I ask at a consultation?

These are the questions that tell you the most. The full checklist has about thirty, with room for notes.

  1. Who will actually work on my case: you, or someone else in your office?
  2. How will you keep me updated, and how often?
  3. Will I get copies of everything filed and every letter with the other side?
  4. How quickly do you usually return calls and emails?
  5. Have you handled cases like mine in my county?
  6. What will make my case cost more or less?
  7. Do you think we can settle, and what happens if we can’t?
  8. Do you also mediate? And can you handle my will afterward?

Ask me all of these too. I’d rather you hire the right lawyer than hire me for the wrong reasons.

What are the red flags?

Watch for these with any lawyer you meet, me included.

  • A promise about how your case will end. No honest lawyer can tell you that. Tennessee’s rules treat lawyer advertising that creates unjustified expectations about results as misleading (RPC 7.1, Comment [3]).
  • No clear explanation of the fee. The rules require the basis of the fee to be explained to you, preferably in writing (more below).
  • Vague answers about keeping you informed.
  • Pressure to decide on the spot. A good lawyer will let you think it over.
  • Encouragement to run down the other parent. Once a divorce is filed and served, an automatic court order bars both spouses from disparaging the other to the children or in front of them (T.C.A. § 36-4-106(d)).
  • No questions about your safety or your children. One of the first things I ask is “Are you safe in your home?”
  • Public discipline on their record that they don’t explain.
Brenda Clark
Free printable checklist

Take the full checklist into every consultation.

About thirty questions, the red flags as tick boxes, what to bring, and a grid to compare up to three lawyers. It opens on this page as soon as you sign up. Show me the checklist

What should I bring to a consultation?

You don’t need everything. Bring what you can reach safely.

  • Any court papers you’ve been served with, and any existing orders, such as a parenting plan or support order
  • Recent tax returns, pay stubs, and bank and retirement statements
  • A list of what you own and what you owe: the house, cars, accounts, loans, credit cards
  • If you have children, their ages and how parenting time works now
  • A short timeline of what’s happened, written down while you remember it
  • Your questions, and what you want your life to look like when this is over
  • A safe phone number or email where the lawyer can reach you

If your phone or computer isn’t private, don’t copy anything onto it. Getting ready for divorce quietly

Is what I tell a lawyer at a consultation private?

Yes. Under Tennessee’s rules, a lawyer may not use or reveal what a prospective client tells them, even if you never hire them (RPC 1.18). So you can be honest at a first meeting. If it isn’t safe for me to call or email you at home, tell me how to reach you.

How do family lawyers charge?

Every lawyer’s fees are different, but the rules are the same for all of them in Tennessee.

  • The basis of the fee must be explained to you, preferably in writing (RPC 1.5(b)).
  • No “you only pay if you win” fees in a divorce or custody case. A Tennessee lawyer can’t charge a fee that depends on getting the divorce, or on the amount of alimony, support or property you receive. The narrow exception is collecting overdue alimony or child support, or enforcing a property order, under conditions (RPC 1.5(d)(1)).

Ask how the fee works, what any money paid up front covers, and whether you’ll get itemized bills.

What makes a case cost more or less is mostly how much the two of you agree on, how many issues there are (children, the house, retirement, a business), how much information has to be dug out, and whether it goes to trial. I like to get it resolved without exorbitant cost, and I’m willing to try to work toward getting it resolved early, before all the money is spent by the client.

I don’t publish fees, and your first consultation with me is free. What a divorce costs, and what drives it

Do I want an aggressive lawyer, or a kind one?

You can have both. Being an aggressive advocate is about knowing what is the most effective way to accomplish your goals, and it should never be turned on you. I save that for the other side. Kind to you, tough in court: what that means

Does it matter if my lawyer is a woman?

For some people it does, and that’s a fair thing to want. When I started private practice, I had just separated from my husband. Even as a strong woman, it was still difficult to deal with emotionally. I think it helped me do a better job, because I had a different way of listening to people. I represent a good balance of men and women. My story

Should my lawyer know my county’s courthouse?

It helps. Each county runs its family courts a little differently. In Davidson County, the Fourth Circuit Court is the court that hears divorces; in Williamson County, divorces are assigned at random to one of four circuit court divisions when they’re filed. Ask any lawyer which courts they appear in.

I take cases in Davidson, Williamson, Sumner and Wilson counties, and work with people in Spring Hill too.

What if we’d rather settle?

Then look for a lawyer who settles cases as readily as they try them. In most Tennessee divorces the court orders you to try mediation anyway (T.C.A. § 36-4-131). I also offer family mediation, for couples who want to work it out together, at nashvillefamilymediator.com.

What others say

“Brenda was very kind, and easy to work with. She was responsive and helpful in answering any and all my questions. -KF”
Kyle F., Google review

Reviews describe one person’s experience, in their own words; spelling is corrected only in [brackets]. Every case is different. Past results don’t guarantee a future outcome. Read every review

Questions people ask about choosing a lawyer

Do I have to decide at the consultation?

No. Take your notes home and compare. Then you decide.

Can we meet by phone or video?

Yes. I meet people at my Nashville office, or by phone or video.

Is your first consultation free?

Yes. Bring your questions, all of them. Schedule it here

Will my spouse find out I talked to a lawyer?

What you tell me in a consultation is kept confidential, even if you don’t hire me. Tell me the safe way to reach you.

Ready to ask me those questions?

Bring the checklist to a free consultation, and ask me anything on it. If I’m not the right fit, I’ll tell you.

Still comparing? Get the full Questions to ask any family lawyer checklist, free.

CallFree consultation